Speedlight or monolight: which flash to choose?
A mid-range or high-end speedlight, fired off-camera on a stand with a compatible trigger, is already enough for a headshot or a chest-up portrait. It is light and easy to move outdoors. Its limits appear as soon as you want to fill a large softbox or preview the shadows: most speedlights do not have a convincing modelling lamp.
A monolight, mains-powered or battery-powered, offers more power, more comfortable recycling and a modelling lamp, which lets you see the Rembrandt triangle or the shadow under the nose before the first exposure. Professional-range monolights (Profoto, Elinchrom, Broncolor, and their mid-range equivalents) also accept larger modifiers.
For a portfolio, consistency matters more than the brand. The essential points are to set the power manually and to fire the flash off the lens axis. The built-in flash, or a speedlight aimed straight at the face from the hot shoe, has no place here: it flattens the features and carves hard shadows under the chin and the nose.
Modifiers: soften the light without losing shape
The softness of a light depends on the apparent size of the source relative to the face. A large softbox close to the subject wraps the skin; the same box, moved back, hardens the shadows. By the inverse square law, doubling the distance also divides the illumination by four. So place the modifier just out of frame, close enough to stay soft.
The softbox
This is the most versatile modifier for a portfolio. The light stays directional, with little spill on the background, and a rectangular box produces a catchlight in the eyes similar to a window. A 60 × 90 cm format, or an octagonal box of about one metre, is enough for a bust portrait; use a larger source for a full-length shot. A honeycomb grid further limits light on the set.
The umbrella
An umbrella goes up in seconds. In its shoot-through form (the flash fires through the fabric), it gives a wide, wrapping light that is harder to contain. As a bounce umbrella, a white interior stays soft; a silver interior adds contrast and wastes less power, as Profoto notes. Outdoors, weight the stand: umbrellas catch the wind.
The beauty dish
A beauty dish places a deflector at the centre of a dish. The look is more sculpted, with sharper shadows and a circular catchlight in the eyes. According to Profoto, the white version is more flattering on skin; the silver version increases contrast. Excellent for a beauty or fashion portrait, it is less forgiving on textured skin. A diffusion sock softens its character.
The reflector: a second source without adding a flash
A reflector is not a second flash. Placed on the opposite side of the key light, about a metre from the model, it bounces some of the light back into the shadows without flattening the face.
- White: a neutral fill, the default choice for a portfolio.
- Silver: more intense — keep it a little farther away and use it with care.
- Gold: warms the skin tone, only if you are prepared to carry that warm cast through the whole series.
- Black (a flag): it absorbs light bouncing off pale walls and deepens the modelling, as Profoto also recommends for Rembrandt lighting.
Three patterns with a single source
Before adding a second flash, master three classic placements. A catchlight from the source should appear in the eyes. If it is missing from the far eye, turn the face slightly towards the light, as you would when directing a model for a natural pose.
Rembrandt lighting
This is the most useful pattern for a portfolio. Raise the light so the shadows fall downwards, then move it to the side until the nose shadow joins the cheek shadow: a small triangle of light then appears on the opposite cheek. Profoto describes this with a softbox just above the face. You can soften the shadow side with a white reflector, or leave it deeper, depending on the mood of the series.
Butterfly lighting
Place the source in front of the model, above the camera, angled down. A small butterfly-shaped shadow forms just under the nose, halfway to the lips. If the eye sockets become too dark, lower the flash slightly. A white reflector under the chin, out of frame, lifts the shadow on the neck and the eyes: the classic “clamshell”. This pattern is particularly well suited to a headshot.
Side lighting
At 90°, the source splits the face in two: one side lit, one side in shadow. The result is more graphic, sometimes harsh. It serves an editorial portrait, a chiaroscuro, a portfolio with a stronger character. A white reflector on the shadow side makes it more approachable, without losing the modelling. It is not the default pattern for a versatile portfolio, but one or two frames treated this way can enrich a series.
Manual metering and flash sync
For a portfolio, work in manual, on the camera and on the flash. TTL remains convenient for reportage, but it changes the exposure as soon as the model changes outfit or background. A portfolio series needs the opposite: the same skin, from one frame to the next.
In a dimly lit room, start at ISO 100 or 200, f/4 to f/5.6, and a shutter speed equal to or just below the camera’s sync speed. Then adjust only the flash power, or the distance of the light, until the lit side of the face is right, with no blown highlights. Shoot RAW, switch on the highlight alert and read the histogram.
In normal sync, shutter speed mainly controls the ambient light. In a dark interior, it barely changes the face. Outdoors or near a large window, it lets you darken or open up the background. Lock the white balance, for example at 5,500 K, a typical “daylight” flash value, or by metering off a grey card. Avoid auto white balance, and switch off the room lights.
Sync speed, and high-speed sync
On a focal-plane shutter, the sensor is fully uncovered only up to a maximum speed, known as X-sync. Beyond that, a dark band appears. This limit depends on the body: Canon quotes typical values of 1/200 s or 1/250 s, and a common range of 1/180 s to 1/250 s depending on the model. Check your camera’s specification and, by default, stay at that speed or below.
High-speed sync (HSS) lifts that barrier. The flash emits a burst of micro-pulses while the shutter slit travels across the sensor. You can then shoot at f/2 or f/2.8 in daylight, blur the background, or darken a bright sky while exposing the face with flash. The trade-off is a loss of usable power: the higher the shutter speed, the lower the effective guide number, as Canon’s manuals point out. In the studio, there is no reason to switch on HSS “just in case”. Keep it for the situations that require it, with compatible gear, and move the light closer or raise the ISO a little if you need to.
Mistakes to avoid
- Leaving the flash on the hot shoe, with no modifier, on the lens axis.
- Pulling the softbox too far back: the shadows harden and the look starts to resemble a bare bulb.
- Exceeding the sync speed without HSS, and ending up with a black band.
- Switching on HSS indoors when you do not need it, then running out of power.
- Exposing in TTL throughout a series meant for a portfolio.
- Forgetting the catchlights in the eyes, which bring the gaze to life.
- Placing a silver reflector too close, especially from below: light from underneath is not flattering.
- Mixing flash, a window in direct sun and the room lights, without controlling the white balance.
- Smoothing the skin too heavily in retouching.
- Changing the lighting pattern, the white balance and the contrast on every frame, at the expense of consistency.
Conclusion
For the next session, a minimal setup is enough: a mid-range or high-end off-camera flash, a medium softbox just out of frame, and a white reflector on the shadow side. Set ISO 100, f/5.6 and the camera’s sync speed, place a Rembrandt pattern, then adjust only the flash power until the skin looks right. From there, move towards butterfly lighting and, if the brief allows, towards a more lateral light. A short, consistent series, carefully edited, will serve the portfolio better than twenty mismatched experiments. The mistakes to avoid in a model portfolio often come down to the final image selection.